On 20 October 2026, the Planning and Environment Court published its reasons for extending the date for completion of NuGrow Ipswich’s new In-Vessel Composting System to 21 January 2027 in Chief Executive of the Department of Environment and Science v NuGrow Ipswich Pty Ltd (No. 2) [2026] QPEC 37. The Department had opposed NuGrow’s application.
NuGrow welcomes the Court’s decision to grant its application to amend the Amended Final Order (AFO), subject to additional conditions. The amended AFO allows construction of the new In-Vessel Composting System to continue while the existing interim measures remain in place.
Read the full decision here.
What the Court found
The interim odour-control system has performed well. The Court found that “the evidence comfortably establishes that the MAF System [Mobile Aerated Floor System] … has performed well and successfully reduced the risk of odour nuisance beyond the boundaries of the facility” [21].
The risk of odour nuisance during the extension will remain low. The Court found that “the risk of odour nuisance beyond the boundary of the site during the period September 2026 to January 2027 would be low” and that continued operation of the system “will not materially increase the risk of offensive odour, or odour nuisance” during the four-month extension [30].
Maintaining the interim measures protects the community. The Court found that refusing the extension would cause “the obligation to operate the interim measures, including the MAF System” to cease [61]. The Court concluded that this would “increase rather than minimise the risk of odour nuisance to the public” and would not represent “a good outcome in the public interest” [66]–[67].
The Court did not accept the assumption underlying the Department’s changed position. Although NuGrow’s environmental authority (EA) has since been amended, the Department’s position at the time of the hearing in September 2026 was different. The Court observed that “the Department, through its litigation unit, changed [its] position” and made clear that the Chief Executive would not amend the EA by agreement, as had occurred on earlier occasions. The Court found that this change appeared to assume that the public would be worse off if the AFO and EA were amended as proposed by NuGrow, stating: “I do not accept this assumption is correct” [33].
Other findings of the Court
A $29 million project, well advanced. The In-Vessel System is a complex infrastructure project involving a capital investment of approximately $29 million. The Court accepted evidence that construction was substantially advanced and that NuGrow remained committed to completing the project. By September 2026, foundations and earthworks had been completed, aeration pipework had been installed, concrete slabs had been constructed, walls had been built for nine of the 12 tunnels, and work on the roofs and biofilters was underway, with more than $5 million of work completed [19], [55]–[56].
The delay was explained and arose from several factors. The Court found that the delay resulted from a combination of design, procurement and construction issues and that “no single factor is to blame”. The Court found that some, but not all, of those issues were beyond NuGrow’s control. This included delays associated with procuring project materials, some of which had long lead times [23], [54]. The Court did not accept the Department’s contention that the delay had not been satisfactorily explained [68]–[69].
NuGrow has made substantial progress and remains committed to completing the project. The Court accepted that NuGrow “has gone to considerable effort to comply” and “is committed to completing” the In-Vessel System [20], [55]–[56].
The Court found that the Department’s “sitting on its hands” criticism was overstated. The Court found that characterisation “overstated”, noting NuGrow told the Department in June 2026 that the September date would not be met [24]–[25], and accepted that this part of the Department’s case “created a false impression” and that the points were overstated [73].
The revised completion date is supported by detailed project programming. The Court accepted evidence from NuGrow’s Project Manager that the In-Vessel System could be installed, commissioned and operational by 20 January 2027. That date was described as the “worst case scenario”, with the system potentially operational by 6 January 2027 if the identified risks do not eventuate [28]. The Court extended the formal completion date to 21 January 2027 [74]–[76].
The extension is subject to increased reporting and oversight. The Court imposed additional reporting conditions to ensure that the Department receives timely information and can monitor NuGrow’s future compliance with the AFO [72]–[76]. NuGrow will provide the Department with fortnightly construction progress reports, monthly project reports and written notice within two business days of becoming aware of anything that might affect the January 2027 completion date. Odour-control reporting will occur monthly, and the interim odour-control measures will remain in place until the In-Vessel System Date. The Court will review the project’s progress on 3 December 2026.